Sydney Opera House panto sparks more trans worries

Christmas pantomime TrAnnie is insulting but anti-discrimination bosses are struggling to handle complaint, say trans campaigners

Sydney Opera House panto sparks more trans worries
19 October 2012

Sydney Opera House’s decision to stage a pre-Christmas pantomime, TrAnnie, which has offended transgender people is making waves beyond the artistic sphere.

The show at the iconic Australian venue is by popular drag performer Trevor Ashley. It’s based around a ‘he/she’ [sic] protagonist in a spoof of the New York-based musical Annie.

Trans activists are arguing laws to protect the trans minority as well as the institutions to uphold that law, appear biased against them. And some have claimed the state anti-discrimination body is, itself, guilty of discrimination.

The concerns come as the New South Wales Anti-Discrimination Board (ADB) begins replying to formal complaints that TrAnnie is guilty of vilification of the trans community, as set out in the NSW Anti-Discrimination Act 1977.

This act makes it illegal to ‘incite hatred towards, serious contempt for or severe ridicule of a person… on the ground of the transgender status of those persons’.

According to response that we have seen to date, the ADB will not at this stage look at complaints about the panto itself, on the grounds that as it has not yet been performed, it does not yet constitute a ‘public act’ within the meaning of the law.

Meanwhile, transgender campaigners are concerned the advertising material for TrAnnie which they consider incites serious hatred through the language used and through releasing details of the shows plot, which directly associates trans people with sexual perversity and pedophilia.

The name of the show, they say, is an insulting word, on a par with ‘faggot’ or ‘nigger’.

The ADB has also created concern by refusing to consider complaints by someone who has not ‘identified themselves’ as being transgendered. This is in line with state law. But it ignores the issues facing many trans men and women who, post-transition, prefer to ‘go stealth’ and not identify as trans.

We have heard from one individual who preferred to drop a case for discrimination against a former employer, rather than undergo the humiliation of being forced to out herself in order to comply with the demands of the ADB.

ADB president Stepan Kerkyasharian confirmed to us: ‘Only members of the vilified group can make complaints to the Anti-Discrimination Board. Therefore the board must satisfy itself of the identity of the complainant and the belonging to a relevant group.’

In one instance where we have seen the ADB’s official response, this is also the line they have taken with a potential complainant. But it’s not clear what proof is needed to comply with their requirements.

The New South Wales ADB website contains two conflicting definitions of who is covered by the law and who, therefore, they consider to be trans.

In one explanation whether or not you are counted as transgender under NSW anti-discrimination law appears to be simply a matter of self-identification, with no hormones, surgery or documentary proofs required.

Further down the same page, a very different definition is provided. It states transgender people need to ‘have a new birth certificate’ from one of a list of recognized bodies.

Kerkayasharian declined to provide any further response to criticism of the ADB’s handling of this matter. He has, however, since written explaining that in order to qualify as a complainant, an individual need only identify as trans in their complaint. He has also stated that the ADB’s position is in line with the requirements of NSW law in this respect.

The decision of the ADB is now likely to be escalated to the Administrative Decisions Tribunal, which acts to provide ‘independent, external review of administrative decisions’.

Watch the promotional video for TrAnnie here:

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Pope Francis has met with France’s gay nominee to be ambassador to the Vatican

Pope Francis reportedly met with openly gay French diplomat Laurent Stefanini over the weekend to tell him that he could not accept his appointment to become an ambassador to the Vatican City
No thumbnail available

FIFA urged to tackle anti-gay laws in Russia, Qatar before World Cups

Fears for safety of gay football players and fans when World Cup goes to anti-gay countries Russia and Qatar in 2018 and 2022
No thumbnail available

We love the 10,000 who love GSN

Gay Star News hits 10,000 likes on Facebook: And we say a massive thank you for all your amazing support
No thumbnail available

Glee’s Puck and Finn become new Kurt and Blaine

Straight characters Puck and Finn will swap bodies with gay couple Kurt and Blaine in an upcoming episode
No thumbnail available

Boy George, Elton John, Jane Lynch, David Hockney among the Out 100

But Anderson Cooper conspiciously absent from annual list this time around
No thumbnail available

South Carolina town mayor fires lesbian police chief for being gay

The newly elected mayor of Latta, South Carolina, has fired his town’s well-liked lesbian chief of police for investigating one of his political appointees and for being gay
No thumbnail available

Vatican archbishop backtracks on pro-gay comments

Vincenzo Paglia, who said the Catholic Church should fight anti-gay laws, has said the media 'derailed' his comments
No thumbnail available

HIV-positive gay man may avoid US deportation on persecution claims

Immigration officials are reconsidering deporting Miguel Rosiles-Camarena from the US after he claimed he would be targeted in Mexico for being HIV-positive and openly gay
Peter Tatchell highlights: the first 60 years

Peter Tatchell highlights: the first 60 years

The start of a three-part interview with gay activist Peter Tatchell, who is 60 tomorrow; including the moment he tried to arrest President Mugabe
No thumbnail available

Broadway star is making 'Noise'

Gavin Creel releases his anthem for marriage equality as a benefit single and video