Tasmania rejects same-sex marriage

Same-sex marriage bill rejected by eight to six in the upper house

Tasmania rejects same-sex marriage
27 September 2012

A vote in the upper house of the Australian state of Tasmania has seen same-sex marriage rejected.

The vote was close with eight opposing and six supporting the bill, but as the debate continued it became clear that it would not go the same way as in the lower house, where it passed 13 to 11 last month.

The debate, which began yesterday and lasted from 11am to 9.30pm today, heard from all 15 MLCs. The chamber was full of members of the public including representatives from religious groups.

Arguments against were characterised with caution, with many MLCs stating that this issue should be decided nationally, not at state level.

Supporters Michael Gaffney and Ruth Forrest emphasized that the bill was about ending discrimination, but Rosemary Armitage who opposed questioned how much the bill would end do that.

Armitage said the legislation was a ‘second class marriage bill’ because it would only be binding in Tasmania and it might be challenged in the High Court as unconstitutional.

Independent MLC James Wilkinson agreed that it would be ‘irresponsible’ to pass a law that may be unconstitutional.

Legal advice about the constitutionality of the bill was colored by the fact that some was circulated by anti-gay-marriage group FamilyVoice. Wilkinson said that this was no reason not to trust the recommendations of the lawyer involved.

Another independent MLC Ivan Dean said that he had received more emails against the bill than supporting it (1,301 to 1,072).

When it became clear that the bill was going to be defeated, independent same-sex marriage supporter Gaffney said ‘I am truly truly sorry’ followed by applause from the public gallery.  

After the federal government rejected bills last week, marriage equality advocates had hoped the states, starting with Tasmania, would legislate for same-sex marriage.  

Australian Marriage Equality national convener and Tasmanian local Rodney Croome, who has campaigned rigorously for the other outcome, said:

‘Today in Tasmania we came closer to allowing same-sex couples to marry than ever before in Australia.
 
‘The fact that most upper house members who voted against of this bill cited constitutional issues as the problem shows we have won the marriage equality debate even though the bill was lost.

‘We will never rest until same-sex couples can marry.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

British gay play producer calls Uganda deportation ‘crazy’

David Cecil is appealing the decision but will likely be months before he sees his Ugandan girlfriend and two children again
No thumbnail available

Gay teen banned from wearing tux boycotts prom

Claudetteia Love and her family are standing up to her school’s position that 'girls wear dresses and that’s just the way it is'
15 photos that prove red heads are the sexiest men in the world

15 photos that prove red heads are the sexiest men in the world

If you can’t meet the smoking hot models at the Red Hot exhibit’s New York premiere today, at least you can drool over their photos right now
No thumbnail available

The White House launches LGBT video contest

Champions of Change challenge to spotlight people who have made positive impact
No thumbnail available

Lesbian in Florida wins $10 million lottery prize, celebrates with wife

Tara Tuttle: 'I had a feeling that it was a lucky ticket'
No thumbnail available

16th annual Gay Easter Parade takes over New Orleans’ French Quarter

The drag kings and queens were out in force in New Orleans on Sunday to raise money for people with HIV through the city’s annual Gay Easter Parade
No thumbnail available

'Hoax' gay Jesus film accused of blasphemy

A movie which depicts Jesus and the Apostles as gay continues to draw complaints in UK, despite never existing
No thumbnail available

Priest 'inadvertently' projects gay porn during meeting

Father Martin McVeigh claims to have no knowledge of how incident occurred
No thumbnail available

NFL quarterback Aaron Rodgers: 'I'm not gay'

Green Bay Packers star refutes reports by explaining 'I really, really like women'
No thumbnail available

eBay says this Christmas Rudolph rainbow t-shirt is gay fetish wear

Lesbian couple is dumbfounded after being told selling Christmas rainbow t-shirts and sweaters as ‘gay interest’ breaches eBay’s ‘adult’ policy