Third gender? No thanks, says Australian intersex organization

Gina Wilson president of Organisation Intersex International Australia gives her views on a third gender option on birth certificates

Third gender? No thanks, says Australian intersex organization
12 July 2012

Gina Wilson president of Organisation Intersex International Australia (OII) writes about why they are against having an ‘intersex’ option on birth certificates, as proposed by a Canberra law council this week.

As an organisation with extensive experience with our membership in countries where third sex options are available, we note that such options only serve to marginalize and further discriminate against those categorized as neither male nor female.

Given the current two-sex system is used to discriminate against around 50% of the world’s population we do not see how further categories will relieve discrimination against anyone.

The need for further sex categories has the  feel of  a middle class exercise in do-good engagement without any experience or understanding of the issues.

OII advocates the right of all people to opt-out of the sex categorisation racket and all of the bigotry and prejudice that accompanies it. By not specifying sex on documentation we retain our right to silence on the issue and the opportunity to disembark from this particular adventure.

If a category such as ‘intersex’ was allowed on what basis would one qualify? Would one need medical proof thus pathologizing the category and further legitimizing the current pathologies that support non-consensual surgeries on infants and treatments for adults that are not supported by evidence or longterm studies?

Who would be the gatekeeper of ‘intersex’? Another International Olympic Committee (IOC) like exercise in deciding who is male and who is female, potentially privileging some over others especially if some benefits were attached to winning an ‘intersex’ certificate. ”¨

Would it boil down to the odious exercise of trans-spotting? Outing those who could not produce evidence and whose bodies have already had all traces of their intersex erased by infant surgeries and effectively vilifying them in the process.

What of XX Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia (CAH) folk who would have to battle against the current trend by parents, friends and doctors who steadfastly declare CAH is not in any circumstances intersex? So who decides just what diagnosis is ‘in’ and which is ‘out’? Will people who have lived with the stigma of a non-conforming sex anatomy suffer the indignity of inspection and proof.

How will the issue of secrecy, lack of access to documentation and records, long a plague on intersex individuals and widely reported on by academics and intersex organisations (see Katrina Karkazis’ Fixing Sex for examples) be addressed? 
The Western world has been endeavouring to fix the  discrimination and stigma that accompanies the certification of a human being as female for the better part of two hundred years and still struggles to remedy the problems. Why on earth would another category fare any better?

Then for those who are not: intersex, not male, not female not trans, not twin spirit, not androgynous, not non-gendered, not bi-gendered… ? You get the drift – the possibilities are endless. The descriptors are only limited by human imaginations.

It is time to stop the rot of the inventions of endless categories to provide human beings with access to full human rights and identity. Simply barring discrimination on the basis of sex characteristics will suffice.

For those who want descriptors: have a fill-in box instead of tick boxes, where anything one desires to describe their ‘gender’ may be written. A person’s freely-given indication would be sufficient to qualify them for the descriptor.

Indeed in an equal society there is no reason for sex designators to be included in the vast preponderance of  documentation. The real necessity right now is only for census like information to be gathered so marginalized peoples can be identified and resources can be allocated.

If we were not the subject of discrimination and unfair treatment, only our lovers (and then not always) and our medical practitioner would have a legitimate reason to enquire about our sex parts.

The government and society needs to get their noses out of  our underpants.



No thumbnail available

Nathaniel Johnston: ‘We want to promote a culture of openness and authenticity’

Johnstone, an NHS Leadership & Talent Programme Manager, reflects on the importance of role models, and encouraging people to be themselves at work
No thumbnail available

Gay rights activists criticize Emirates election to UN human rights council

The United Arab Emirates (UAE) has been elected member of the UN human rights council for a three-years, despite its appalling record on the issue, gay rights activists criticize the decision
No thumbnail available

Bullied over being a cheerleader, 12-year-old California boy commits suicide

Ronin Shimizu's family had reported the bullying to school officials multiple times
No thumbnail available

Korean gay couple plan wedding to raise money for LGBT Center

Filmmakers Sunghwan Kim and Gwang-soo Kim Jho plan wedding outside Seoul City Hall in September to raise money for the South Korean LGBT rights movement
No thumbnail available

World Bank suspends $90 million loan to Uganda over anti-gay law as currency dips

Uganda is seeing further financial consequences over the passing of its notorious Anti-Homosexuality Bill that jails gays for life with the World Bank suspending a major development loan
No thumbnail available

Openly gay Belgian PM Elio Di Rupo calls out African leaders on gay rights

The world’s second openly gay leader of a country has told a European Union-Africa leadership summit that the rights of minorities, including LGBTI people must be respected
No thumbnail available

Scissor Sisters' Ana Matronic calls for end to lesbian hate in SA

US performer speaks out in support of Amnesty International's Write for Rights campaign which demands justice for murdered lesbian activist Noxolo Nogwaza
No thumbnail available

Is Thomas Roberts being groomed as the first openly gay network news anchor?

MSNBC host says: 'It would be historic, and I am willing and able'
No thumbnail available

Ireland’s Prime Minister joins Twitter MD and other tech leaders in calling for equal marriage

At an event in Dublin’s Digital Exchange, Ireland’s Taoiseach joined 150 business leaders in calling for the public to vote in favor of same-sex marriage in the republic
No thumbnail available

Gay couples celebrate civil unions in Colorado

Civil unions between same-sex couples became legal in the American state of Colorado today