Turkish court rules gay sex is natural

A court in Istanbul, Turkey made a landmark ruling saying that gay sex is natural

Turkish court rules gay sex is natural
19 February 2013

An Istanbul court of the first instance delivered a landmark ruling saying that gay sex is natural, contradicting a previous ruling by Turkey’s supreme court.

Yesterday’s (18 February) ruling regarded a trader who was caught selling 125 DVDs of gay and group sex porn.

The person, known only by his initials, DM, faced up to four years imprisonment according to article 262/2 of the Turkish penal code that prohibits owning, trafficking, distributing and publishing ‘unnatural sex’ videos.

Judge Mahmut Erdemli, however, ruled that sexual orientation can not be considered as ‘unnatural’ and should be respected.

The ruling contradicted a previous decision of Turkey’s supreme court that did include gay sex in the category of ‘unnatural sex’.

In support of his decision Erdemli cited examples of the legality of gay marriages in Europe and North America.

Erdemli differentiated gay sex from necrophilia and bistiality which he agreed were right to be classified as ‘unnatural’.

Erdemli was quoted by the daily Haber Turk as saying: ‘Today, it is possible to have gay marriages in modern countries.

‘International regulations prohibit discrimination regarding peoples’ sexual preference, and it is therefore an obligation to respect their sexual orientation…

‘In this respect, most of the European countries see gay relationships as equivalent to marriage…

‘Contemporary societies allow [gay relationships] to achieve this legal status and therefore the contents of the DVDs can not be seen as unnatural’.

The court did not find DM guilty of selling ‘unnatural’ porn but of ‘unauthorized’ selling of porn with a punishment of 8 months imprisonment.

Turkey’s criminal division of the supreme court, however, criticized the ruling saying that gay and group sex are unnatural and that the court was wrong not to accept them as a crime.

Last year, in a ruling on a similar case of porn videos sales, Turkey’s supreme court of appeals in Ankara (the country’s capital) ruled as ‘unnatural’ any acts of gay sex, oral, anal or group sex – including SM – as well as necrophilia and bestiality.

The supreme court provided for the imprisonment of any persons in possession of videos depicting such sex scenes on the basis of Article 262/2 of the Turkish criminal code.

The court set a minimum punishment of one year, and a maximum of four years imprisonment.

The supreme court’s ruling of 2012 rejected a six-month sentence imposed by a provincial court for the selling of pornographic videos with ‘unnatural’ content saying the ruling was too lenient.

A spokesperson for Turkish LGBT rights group KAOS GL told GayStarNews: ‘The decision given by the court yesterday is not binding.

‘However it is a positive development that may affect a future ruling by Turkey’s supreme court.

‘Even if the supreme court will not accept this ruling – this sets a very positive precedent for future cases’. 

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

How we should react to the Muslim leader who called hijras ‘dirty’

Gay Muslim advocate Omar Kuddus addresses a video where the president of India’s Islamic Research Centre attacked ‘LGBT’ hijras as ‘defective’
No thumbnail available

India’s Home Affairs Minister says government will not move swiftly on gay sex ban

India’s Home Affairs Minister appears to have indicated the government will likely appeal the Supreme Court’s recriminalization of homosexuality in the courts rather than passing a bill to resolve the issue
No thumbnail available

Gay man called 'faggot' and beaten unconscious in California

Victim: 'They knew I was gay. They knew they were taller and bigger'
No thumbnail available

Gay actor Kevin Clash, puppeteer of Sesame Street’s Elmo, resigns from show

His exit comes amid new allegations of sexual relationship with a minor
No thumbnail available

Are British politicians finally taking trans issues seriously?

Members of the UK parliament from all political backgrounds now seem to be waking up to the issues facing transgender voters
No thumbnail available

US judge places hold on same-sex marriages in Texas

In his decision, Garcia said allowing same-sex couples to marry as the case is appealed 'would only be temporary, with confusion and doubt to follow'
No thumbnail available

Chinese dictionary leaves out popular word for 'gay'

The Chinese gay community’s most popular word to refer to themselves has been left out of a new Chinese dictionary, sparking criticism  
No thumbnail available

A 24-hour, 200 mile bike ride across Britain

We help two brave gay scene celebs cycle from London to Manchester to raise money for Elton John AIDS Foundation
No thumbnail available

Majority of religious Britons support gay marriage, poll shows

YouGov survey for Stonewall flies in the face of Church of England warnings about impact of gay marriage
Spanish bullring owner says better for kids to watch bulls die in the ring than gay pride parades

Spanish bullring owner says better for kids to watch bulls die in the ring than gay pride parades

Circuitos Taurinos co-owner Carlos Zúñinga has angered animal rights activists in Spain after he said it was more damaging for children to witness a gay pride parade than a bullfight