UK gay marriage debate begins today, bishops urged to withhold votes

As a two-day debate on UK marriage equality goes underway in the House of Lords, senior church officials fear a backlash if too many bishops vote against the bill

UK gay marriage debate begins today, bishops urged to withhold votes
03 June 2013

The future of gay marriage in England and Wales will be debated in the House of Lords today and tomorrow.

As the Lords argue the merits of the bill over two days that will culminate in a crunch vote at around 5pm on Tuesday (4 June), bishops have been told to abstain from voting to avoid being singled out and blamed should the bill not pass.

The Telegraph reports bishops are being urged not to submit a vote for gay marriage, for fears that there could be a backlash against the church that may call into question bishops’ right to sit in the House of Lords.

One senior official said to The Telegraph: ‘What they are scared of is that this goes down by a few votes and then the bishops are seen as having swung the vote.’

Though a total of 26 bishops are allowed to sit with the Lords, senior officials have allegedly requested that a maximum of six be present for the debate today and tomorrow (3 and 4 June).

It is set to be a stormy debate with 80 peers due to speak. But it will give opponents and gay marriage supporters the chance to debate the broad principle of marriage equality.

Campaigners for marriage equality remain confident about the process but warn it will be historically tight.

Helen Grant, the justice and equalities minister, has said votes should be cast in favor of same-sex marriage because it’s the right thing to do, not because of Cameron’s promises to give tax breaks to all married couples in 2015.

‘This [same-sex marriage debate] is about stopping discrimination and allowing a very large and significant group of people to enter into an institution that most of us think is a very valuable one. That is really how I see it.’

Grant said same-sex couples shouldn’t accept tax breaks as a trade-off for legalized marriage, which is one option expected to be brought up in the two-days’ debate.

Senior officials in the Anglican Church, according to the Telegraph, have also told bishops the current bill, which includes a ‘lock’ that prevents religious leaders being forced to conduct same-sex ceremonies is the ‘best’ the church can hope for.

In addition to the Anglican Church’s strong opposition to the marriage equality bill, religious leaders from various UK faith groups have formed ‘unprecedented’ alliances to speak out against gay marriage.

A Church of England spokesman said: ‘The bishops in the House of Lords do not have a party whip, they do not vote according to a party line.

‘Each will vote according to their own conscience.’

Head of policy for Stonewall, the UK’s leading gay lobby group, Sam Dick said: ‘We expect a tough fight in the House of Lords and we’re working tirelessly to help the bill get through second reading.

‘By supporting this modest measure peers will demonstrate that they’re in touch with British public opinion in the 21st rather than the 19th century.’

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

No thumbnail available

Tennessee judge finds gay marriage ban constitutional in shock ruling

A Tennessee county judge has ruled that the US constitution does not protect same-sex couples’ right to marry in the first legal loss of its kind since the US Supreme Court overturned the federal Defense Of Marriage Act
No thumbnail available

Good Morning America's gay weather anchor is leaving ABC after 25 years

Sam Champion accepts 'amazing opportunity' with the Weather Channel
No thumbnail available

Alaska Supreme Court rules in favor of LGBTI families

'Our senior citizens and veterans should not have to pay more taxes just because they happen to be gay or lesbian'
No thumbnail available
No thumbnail available

Gay playwright Alan Bennett blasts Margaret Thatcher in diary extracts

British playwright Alan Bennett accuses former UK Prime Minister Baroness Margaret Thatcher of being a ‘mirthless bully’ in published diary extracts
No thumbnail available

Estonia: 35,000 sign petition to oppose legal recognition of same-sex couples

A petition against the recognition of gay couples has garnered triple the signatures expected by organizers
No thumbnail available

Muscles in Brussels: dancing in the street and too many mojitos at Pride.be

80,000 turn out for climactic day of Belgian Pride
No thumbnail available

Italian educator working in North Africa deported for being gay

Eritrea has labeled professor Paolo Mannina ‘a dangerous individual who is potentially destabilizing to the moral order and public of the country’
No thumbnail available

Costa Rican lawyers claim ‘accidental’ bill does nothing for same-sex unions

Constitutional lawyers say that same-sex couples still lack the ‘legal capacity’ to enter into any type of civil unions.
No thumbnail available

Hillary Clinton praises Arizona governor Jan Brewer's veto of anti-gay bill

Unofficial US presidential hopeful tells Florida college students that 'inclusive leadership is really what the 21st century is all about'