Why I think it’s time for a shock campaign on HIV

Defending the new HIV testing advert which features a man lifting gym weights in an electric chair

Why I think it’s time for a shock campaign on HIV
27 September 2012

Featuring a man in an electric chair in an HIV ad campaign was always going to spark a reaction.

So it’s no surprise that the advert I created in response to a competition for a new way to highlight undiagnosed HIV infection is already prompting debate.

The idea behind the campaign was to present the unknown in a visual sense: I did this by presenting a man in the gym training whilst strapped to an electric chair.

The electric chair works as the metaphor for the undiagnosed HIV infection and the death sentence that it ultimately can be (if left untreated). I wanted the image to hit hard and to shock as an initial reaction. But equally important was to educate that early diagnosis can now lead to a normal life expectancy – an important fact which many still might not be aware of.

The concept was inspired by phrases such as ‘out of sight, out of mind’ and ‘ignorance is not bliss’. I also looked at past HIV and AIDS awareness campaigns and thought about why they did or didn’t work.

I always knew I wanted to create something with a darker undertone, but I realized it was a risky move as I felt it was probably too far removed from what the gay community was familiar with. So when it was announced that I’d won the competition I was really appreciative as it meant others believed in my idea too.

Since I was announced as the winner, I’ve heard a mixture of good and bad reviews about the campaign.

The bad reviews mainly come from people claiming that using scare tactics isn’t the right approach. My argument is that with one in seven gay men on on London’s LGBT scene, now is not the time to use tamer antics.

I have also directly asked a lot of the people who were quick to criticize how they would’ve approached the subject. To this I usually get no answer or that I should have conveyed that being HIV positive isn’t a ‘big deal’ anymore. I don’t agree. Just because the virus is now controllable, the emphasis on prevention shouldn’t be sidetracked.

I did a lot of research before hand into studies that suggest shock advertising is much more effective in gaining people’s attention and is much more likely to influence behavior.

From personal experience the campaigns I’ve previously seen and been influenced by are ones that shocked, provoked or caused me to question their meaning. I think an effective campaign will ultimately do one of those three.

I’ve seen posters in the past in clubs and bars of buff men holding up condoms with captions like ‘Stay safe’, and I always questioned their relevance. Maybe those adverts work for some people, but for me they didn’t, which is why I think a mixture of advertising techniques should always be used.

I think it’s undeniable that promiscuity in the gay community has escalated in recent years. I’m inclined to believe this is mainly driven by dating websites and phone applications which a high percentage of men use to arrange hook-ups. I’m not here to judge anyone’s behavior; I just think it goes without saying that if promiscuity increases then so should sexual health awareness.

The campaign will run on Gay Star News from Monday (1 October). See it here:

HAVE YOUR SAY

MORE TOP STORIES

Leaving Johnny Hazzard behind, we meet Frankie Valenti – actor.

Leaving Johnny Hazzard behind, we meet Frankie Valenti – actor.

Gay Star News talks to the surprising star of new movie Tiger Orange
No thumbnail available

Watch: Conan O'Brien meets up with a guy on Grindr

'I've been married happily for a long time, but then there are times – like when Ryan Gosling’s on the show'
No thumbnail available

Malaysia investigates missing civil partner

Ariff Alfian Rosli’s return demanded by Muslim groups after he married his partner in Ireland
No thumbnail available

White House race 2012: Mitt Romney and gay rights

In the first of a special two-part feature, GSN looks at Barack Obama’s challenger in the 2012 presidential election, Mitt Romney, and his LGBT record
No thumbnail available

Obama cracks hilarious joke about Indiana pizzeria that refused to cater gay weddings

President also pokes fun at politicians who won't attend gay weddings
No thumbnail available

Queer Nation New York uses Coca-Cola ad to protest Sochi Games

1970s commercial selling love and Coca-Cola gets remade into protest about the Winter Olympics
London teen to lose virginity as part of live gay sex ‘art’ show

London teen to lose virginity as part of live gay sex ‘art’ show

Up to 500 people could watch as an art student claims he will lose his cherry in a 'once-in-a-lifetime performance'
No thumbnail available

Queer Nation stage plane banner protest over Ian Reisner’s Fire Island business empire

Gay businessmen Ian Reisner and Mati Weiderpass continue to face calls for a boycott after hosting Republican politician Ted Cruz at their Manhattan home
No thumbnail available

Hate crimes in Chile now punishable by law

Four months after the brutal gay bashing of 24-year-old Daniel Zamudio ignited a global outry, President Sebastian Pinera makes anti-discrimination law official
Welcome to the new Gay Star News

Welcome to the new Gay Star News

Fully upgraded site now live, even more improvements coming