Yes, gay marriage opponent Lord Carey is a bigot

Kiki Archer explains the meaning of ‘bigot’ to George Carey, the former Archbishop who says gay marriage opponents are being treated like Jews during the Nazi era

Yes, gay marriage opponent Lord Carey is a bigot
10 October 2012

When British Prime Minister David Cameron pledged his full support for equal marriage he made a very simple and very clear statement: ‘I don’t support gay marriage despite being a Conservative. I support gay marriage because I am a Conservative.’

Hoorah for the gay community, we all shouted, about time too! So why on earth, six months on, during a Conservative Party Conference fringe event in Birmingham this week, are we, the LGBT community, subjected to the vile, homophobic rants of vocal members of his party?

The question at the heart of the furore caused by Conservative ex-minister Anne Widdecombe and former Archbishop of Canterbury Lord George Carey’s recent outspoken disapproval of gay marriage, is this: Can we call people who oppose gay marriage bigots? For me the answer is simple.

‘Bigot: Noun: One who is strongly partial to one’s own group, religion, race, or politics and is intolerant of those who differ.’

Anne Widdecombe asked the following question to a crowd of supporters at Birmingham Town Hall on Monday lunchtime (8 October): ‘Is it bigoted to recognize that the complementarity of a man and a woman in a union open to procreation is unique and cannot be replicated by other unions?’

Well, Anne, let’s have a look at my life… a life that where my union ‘replicates’ that of a man and a woman, almost identically. We fell in love. We brought a house. We entered into a committed civil partnership. We gave birth to two children. We are a family. We pay taxes. Both adults work and contribute to society. Both children go to school.

We are the most ‘traditional’ union that you could find. The only difference is that my partner is of the same sex.

So, Anne, the answer to your question is clearly yes, it is bigoted. You are intolerant to the fact same sex couples can procreate and lead completely ‘normal’ family lives. Not to mention the gaping flaws in your argument concerning straight couples who can’t conceive children naturally, or elderly couples who wish to marry with absolutely no intension of starting a family.

Lord Carey, the former head of the Church of England and worldwide Anglican Church, took it a step further.

He tried to compare campaigners against gay marriage to persecuted Jews in Nazi Germany.

He said: ‘Remember the Jews in Nazi Germany. What started against them was when they were called names. And that was the first stage towards that totalitarian state. We have to resist them. We treasure democracy. We treasure our Christian inheritance and we want to debate this in a fair way.’

So, does Lord Carey have a right to feel persecuted for his views? Again, the answer for me is simple.

Do racists have the right to feel persecuted for their views? No.

Do sexists have the right to feel persecuted for their views? No.

Do ageists have the right to feel persecuted for their views? No.

Do people who discriminate based on disability, class, or other ism that is degrading to a certain group of people, have the right to feel persecuted for their views? The answer is so simple: Of course not!

If you substitute the word homosexual for any other minority group you realize how truly awful homophobia is. ‘Black people should not be given the right to get married.’ ‘Disabled people should not be given the right to get married.’ ‘Old people should not be given the right to get married.’ It is so utter ridiculous that it beggars belief that these people even dare to say it, let alone feel they have a right to say it and not be criticized for it or branded bigots.

No one is suggesting Lord Carey be locked up in a ghetto or shipped off to Auschwitz. We are just demanding that homophobic rants get treated in the same manner as racist rants, or sexists rants: Condemned and ignored.

This is my life that these politicians are dismissing. This is my family. This is me. How dare they?

Kiki Archer is a best-selling lesbian novelist and vocal advocate for LGBT rights. Visit her site here or follow her on Twitter here.



No thumbnail available

Mad Men's Kit Williamson on his engagement: 'It's important young LGBTIs see their futures can be full of love'

Actor speaks to Gay Star News ahead of upcoming nuptials with John Halbach
RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars 2 confirmed

RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars 2 confirmed

They arrived as drag artists and left as international stars, but who will make it to the Drag Hall of Fame?
No thumbnail available

Ireland bishop compares gay people to Down syndrome

Catholic bishop says LGBTI people with children 'are not parents'
No thumbnail available

A truly awesome escape to the beaches of Tropical North Queensland

In need of some star-gazing and wallaby-watching, Gareth Johnson leaves the world behind for a slower pace of life in Australia's idyllic beach town Port Douglas
No thumbnail available

Daniel Sprich: ‘There is a German saying, "Work is work, and private is private"'

Sprich works in the oil and gas industry as a systems advisor for BP. Here he talks about the differences in work culture regarding LGBTI issues between Germany and the UK
No thumbnail available

Lesbian astronaut Sally Ride awarded Presidential Medal of Freedom

Sally Ride was the first American woman in space and the first known LGBT astronaut
No thumbnail available

Arkansas teacher fired from Catholic school after marrying her partner of 14 years

Teacher Tippi McCullough married her partner in New Mexico, only to be told by the principal she should resign or face 'public firing'
No thumbnail available

Family Research Council links Dan Savage to frat's racist rant

'...Here’s a guy that’s responsible for the coarsening of civil discussion and conversation being celebrated...'
No thumbnail available

A gay dad sounds off on Nancy Grace defending anti-gay bigot Anita Bryant

Rob Watson has written an open letter to HLN host Nancy Grace about her defending a woman who described gay men as pedophiles
No thumbnail available

New Australian transgender film festival seeks submissions

The inaugural Tilde Melbourne Trans & Gender Diverse Film Festival is seeking submissions from transgender and gender diverse filmmakers and films that explore transgender and gender diverse themes